Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process in Dawaat Journal

Dawaat Journal is committed to applying the highest standards of integrity and objectivity in the scientific peer review process, following a precise and transparent review mechanism aimed at ensuring the quality of the published research. The peer review process follows the steps outlined below:

1. Submission of the Research:

   • Researchers are required to submit their papers through the journal's website (http://dawatjournal.com), ensuring compliance with the journal's publishing guidelines (submission criteria).

2. Initial Check:

   • After submission, the editorial team reviews the papers to ensure they comply with the journal's basic specifications regarding the topic, style, and scientific structure.

3. Double-Blind Peer Review:

   • The peer review process follows the double-blind system, where the paper is sent to specialized reviewers in the relevant scientific field.

   • Reviewers do not know the identities of the authors, and authors do not know the identities of the reviewers, ensuring impartiality and objectivity in the evaluation.

   • Reviewers assess the paper based on several scientific criteria, including originality, scientific quality, methodology, accuracy in presenting results and interpretations, and proper documentation.

4. Evaluation and Decision:

   • After receiving the reviewers' reports, the editorial team reviews them and makes a decision on whether to accept, reject, or request revisions for the paper.

   • If revisions are required, the reviewers' comments are sent to the authors to make the necessary changes, and the paper is resubmitted for review.

5. Plagiarism and Originality Check:

   • All submitted papers are subject to plagiarism detection using Turnitin to ensure originality and prevent any manipulation of sources.

6. Informing Authors of the Decision:

   • Authors are informed of the final decision regarding their paper (acceptance, rejection, or revision), along with details of the reviewers' comments, if available.

7. Publishing the Paper:

   • After final acceptance, the paper is published in the specified issue of the journal according to the journal’s regular publication schedule.

8. Transparency and Integrity:

   • The journal is fully committed to transparency throughout all stages of the peer review process and ensures no interference with the independence of reviewers or authors.

   • The journal guarantees the confidentiality of information and ensures no manipulation of the review outcomes.

This process is carried out with great accuracy to ensure the publication of reliable scientific research that contributes to the advancement of academic knowledge across various fields.